Call Boxes.

This the place to have frank, but cordial, discussions of the Lizzie Borden case

Moderator: Adminlizzieborden

Post Reply
User avatar
Allen
Posts: 3408
Joined: Mon Dec 06, 2004 3:38 pm
Gender: Female
Real Name: Me

Call Boxes.

Post by Allen »

I have always wondered why the first people to be called to the scene that day were not the police. I found this bit of testimony fascinating as it indicates there was a system of police call boxes in place in Fall River at that time. The police call box was a city wide alarm system. This is something I never thought of before. But given my line of study I always find things of this nature fascinating, so forgive me if I bring up a topic that to you all seems not quite as interesting as it does for me. :smile: :oops: And if it was nearby why was the box not used to alert the police back at the station on the day of the murder? Why did the officer walk back to inform them of the situation?

Trial testimony John Coughlin page 1162:

( This pertains to the visit made to the Borden home on Saturday evening.)

Q. As you approached toward the house did you see any persons on the street?
A. I saw a large number of people congregated around the Borden house.

Q. What was done with reference to those people?
A. I instructed the marshal to have them removed.

Q. Were they removed?
A. They were.

Q.Can you give us an idea of about how much of a crowd there was there on the street?
A. The sidewalk on the east side was some little distance down, both north and to the south, was crowded with people. The middle of the street--- there were a large number of people gathered there, and, in fact, it was with difficulty, that we were able to drive through without running some of them down. I notified the marshal that they should be removed. We drove to a police box, he got out of the carriage and pulled in the box.

Q. Well, I don't care to go into the details. The officers were called?
A. Yes, sir.


During the 1800's there were police alarm systems that could be used to call for assistance in case the need arose. They were, however, usually kept locked to avoid false alarms. I wondered if citizens as well as officers had access to using this alarm system. So I did a little checking around. Most of the information I found pertaining to alarm systems of this nature were the ones used by the fire department. But both systems worked using the same principle. There seems to have been a variance in the manner in which citizens had access to these alarms. The most common practice seems to have been to entrust the keys to residents who had places of business near the call box, or if there were no businesses close by, to citizens who were deemed responsible enough by the community. There were other sites that gave some pretty detailed information this is just one description I found for the police call box. It was on a site that describes systems that were in place in Chicago during the 1800's.


By 1879, the Chicago Police Department approached their alert and response problem with a radical new idea, the police box. Using the original concept of the firebox used by the CFD in the early 1870s, the CPD erected a new advanced alert system for beat patrolmen. An officer, while walking his beat, would notice a crime being committed. If the situation warranted more assistance then he himself could provide, he would race to the local police box, a wooden structure approximately six feet in height that looked like a telephone booth. Inside this signal box was another box that contained the signal system. The patrolman would move the activator (dial and pointer) and choose one of a number of options, including riot, murder, fire, and forgery.18 Other options were available, such as tones for a line check. The booths were also attached to a streetlamp with a glass section to the roof so that the officer could use the ambient light to see the alarm box. When the alarm was activated at the site a signal box at the station would ring. It would denote the box from which the alarm was sent so that a response force could be sent as soon as possible. For example, if an officer had made an arrest he would turn the annunciator to arrest on box number 287. The alarm for box 287 would ring at the station, showing an arrest, and then a police wagon should be sent for pickup. All officers on patrol and officers in the station manning the telegraph systems were required to know the location of each patrol box. Furthermore, the exact locations of each existing and newly-added box were published in the Police Superintendent's annual report.19

The city boosters touted this system as a godsend against "terror gangs" as well as a technological advance that would help maintain law and order.20 As with the firebox system, local citizens of civic reliability were issued keys to open the alarm boxes. The citizen's keys were held fast in the lock opening by a trap lock. When the officer responding to the call arrived, he used his master key to remove the citizen's key. If a person had called in a false report with a stolen key the officer had the numbered citizen key. He could check the number against a list of people who had the key and could follow up with the particular individual, or he could cancel the alarm from the box.21 It was a benefit for officers as well as citizens. Until this new system was instituted an officer had to walk back to the station to report any incidents that might require help. Often, by the time the officers returned to the scene, the perpetrators had left. This old system of walking back to the station was made even more difficult in the event of an arrest. The officer would have to walk his prisoner back to the station, often with nothing restraining the prisoner except the sense of shame for committing the criminal act. This system of arrest and "transport" proved cumbersome, if not impossible, when an officer had to arrest several people. With the alarm system in place, help could be dispatched to retrieve prisoners or send further help. This response team required the other major technological invention to the CPD's arsenal: the police wagon.22



http://www.findarticles.com/p/articles/ ... 08871/pg_4
"He who cannot put his thoughts on ice should not enter into the head of dispute." - Friedrich Nietzsche
User avatar
Kat
Posts: 14770
Joined: Sun Dec 28, 2003 11:59 pm
Real Name:
Location: Central Florida

Post by Kat »

Thanks! That was interesting.
It sounds like it needed electricity. And a pole.
I don't think we've seen any electric poles on Second Street in that time period. So Coughlin's man would still have to go off-street to send for help.

I wonder what "pulled in the box" meant, in that testimony?
User avatar
Allen
Posts: 3408
Joined: Mon Dec 06, 2004 3:38 pm
Gender: Female
Real Name: Me

Post by Allen »

I found this it of information on the Keeley Library site. It can be found found under the heading:


History of Fall River / prepared under the direction of a committee of prominent citizens appointed by His Honor Mayor John T. Coughlin by Henry M. Fenner, A. B., assisted by Benjamin Buffinton. -- New York : F. T. Smiley Publishing Co., 1906.
364 p. : ill., ports. ; 28 cm.
Contents:


And by clicking on the appropriate chapter:

Chapter X. Fire and Police: Sketch of the Beginnings and Development of Two Strong Departments of the Municipality, p. 67-71. (1,067K)



Information found in reference to the fire department:

" The Gamewell fire alarm telegraph system was established on January 7, 1870, to succeed the old method of bell ringing. The first alarm was given from box 16 on January 27."


Then information found in reference to the police department:

"The patrol wagon system went into effect in 1890, and the first call was answered January 12. The box system was established at this time."

So it seems there was a system of call boxes in place at the time of the murders. To pull in the box would mean to sound the alarm. So my original question in this thread is posed again.

Information on the system.
http://plaws.net/fire/box.html

http://uv201.com/Misc_Pages/gamewell.htm
"He who cannot put his thoughts on ice should not enter into the head of dispute." - Friedrich Nietzsche
User avatar
Smudgeman
Posts: 728
Joined: Wed Nov 03, 2004 7:51 am
Real Name: Scott
Location: Atlanta, GA

Post by Smudgeman »

I wonder what citizens in Lizzie's neck of the woods would have been trusted to have a key to one of these call boxes? Surely the good doctor Bowen, and perhaps Andrew as well? Surely Mrs. Churchill or Alice Russell knew who would have such a key. That would seem to be their system of 911 as we know it today, yet they opted for a doctor instead? Maybe everyone knew the police were away and not readily available that day, I don't know?
"I'd luv to kiss ya, but I just washed my hair"
Bette Davis
User avatar
Harry
Posts: 4058
Joined: Thu Dec 04, 2003 4:28 pm
Real Name: harry
Location: South Carolina

Post by Harry »

One of the first questions Kieran is asked at the trial (page 89) is:

"Q. How far is it from the Borden house to the central police station going the direct way through the streets?
A. I measured that distance, sir, and gave the notes of it to Mr. Knowlton this morning. (Notes produced.) Those are the notes. From the Borden house to the central police station is about 1300 feet."

This is almost exactly 1/4 of a mile. Officer Allen in the trial (page 432) is asked:

"Q. How far is it from the station or how many minutes' walk up to it?
A. Four minutes it took me, because I have tried it since.
Q. Did you walk or---
A. Went partly on the run."

He must have been a slow runner. 4 minutes for a quarter of a mile is a brisk walk pace. Due to the shortness of the distance to the Borden house a call box probably would not have saved much time. Its advantages in other circumstances are obvious.

I examined my collection of images of Fall River streets looking for call boxes. Found just one The first shows the Durfee textile plant. On the lower right it looks like a call box. More likely a fire call box considering the number of fires in the mills. The second card shows the Central Congregational Church. Again to the lower right there is a circular object. I have been told that it was a signal terminal box and not a call box.

Image
Image

These images are from postcards and I do not know the year.
I know I ask perfection of a quite imperfect world
And fool enough to think that's what I'll find
User avatar
Kat
Posts: 14770
Joined: Sun Dec 28, 2003 11:59 pm
Real Name:
Location: Central Florida

Post by Kat »

That's cool Harry!
I recall looking for these things before.
Well, if anyone comes across a meter-looking thingy, or phone-booth-looking thing in their postcards or old photos from old books, maybe they will contribute here?

I wonder where the box was located that Coughlin's man used?

I was thinking the same thing Scott about the police being away! Then I realized Coughlin's visit was Saturday, so I guess all the police would be back to work.
That must have been the visit that some think got Lizzie off.
(The visit where the mayor tells her she is suspected and then she is grilled at the inquest, some believe like a suspect, and then her testimony is not allowed etc...)
He should have stayed at home that evening!

Good for you Missy for using the resources at the Keeley Library Online!
Post Reply